How should charities and non-profits invest in their fundraising?
Improving your fundraising performance; it’s a subject to which charity/non-profit leaders and fundraisers must dedicate many hours of thought. It’s no secret that fundraising is complicated and increasing your expenditure will not necessarily lead to a proportionate increase in performance. However, research has shown that cutting your fundraising expenditure will almost always have a negative impact on your fundraising revenue.
To help charities and non-profits maximise their time, energy and resource, our fundraising consultants have broken down some of the top considerations when it comes to fundraising investment.
Human Resources
Your fundraising team and their capabilities are integral to your fundraising performance. Without the right combination of knowledge and skills, it’s unlikely that you’ll be hitting your fundraising targets, so investing in your human resources is vitally important.
The first step here is to take a look at your fundraising goals alongside your current team and ask yourself a few questions:
- Who do you currently have, and what are their skills?
- Do you have the capacity to reach your fundraising goals within your current team?
- If not, what is it that is holding you back?
This should give you an idea of how you need your team to look going forward, and any skills gaps that need filling.
Recruiting vs outsourcing your fundraising
The decision over whether to recruit or outsource your fundraising is a highly personal, challenging consideration. There are benefits and drawbacks to both approaches, which we’ll discuss in passing here – acknowledging that there are many complex factors to account for!
Benefits of recruiting in-house:
- An in-house fundraiser that works exclusively for your organisation every day will gain a comprehensive understanding of your charity and the people you aim to serve. This could help them find and apply for more relevant funding opportunities and compose a detailed, compelling case for support.
- In-house fundraisers who are directly involved in the leadership of your organisation can use their expertise to steer your strategic direction in a way that improves your fundraising performance, so it’s useful to have some level of fundraising expertise on your leadership team.
- An in-house fundraiser may feel like a longer-term solution which provides more stability to your team.
Benefits of outsourcing:
- A fundraising agency will have a wealth of knowledge and experience across the full spectrum of fundraising solutions. This opens up opportunities to develop creative fundraising ideas for your organisation from their experiences with clients in other sectors.
- It can actually be more cost-effective to hire an external agency, rather than spend the money on recruiting, paying and training someone in-house. This is particularly true in today’s competitive fundraising environment; with huge demand for fundraisers (and particularly trusts and foundations specialists!) driving up salary expectations.
- The current recruitment process for fundraisers is long and challenging, followed by several weeks of training and on-boarding. Once you’ve established a relationship with your chosen fundraising agency and explained your aims, they can immediately crack on with implementation – saving you valuable time.
Again, there is no one correct approach to the recruitment vs outsourcing debate, but will depend entirely on what feels right for your charity and its aims.
Digital and tools
It will come as no surprise that investing in your digital fundraising is prominent on this list: according to Blackbaud there has been a 42% increase in online giving over the last three years, with no sign of this slowing down any time soon. With the digital transformation that accompanied the pandemic, charities and non-profits must accept that digital fundraising is here to stay.
The donor journey
It’s important to provide users of any of your digital channels (website, social media, emails etc.) with a simple, efficient journey to donate.
A great place to start could be donor journey mapping: identifying the digital touchpoints (the non-physical interactions between your organisation and its supporters). Where are you currently speaking to them? How do these interactions look? What steps are you asking them to take before they can donate?
Optimising your website for the donor journey doesn’t need to involve website developers and huge expense. Start by thinking about what information visitors are looking for when they visit your website, how you can easily supply that information, and how you can build the donation element into that journey. From there, you can design a simple site with landing pages that fulfil those roles.
Finally, it might sound obvious, but ensure all your donation buttons are prominent: this will make it clear to users that your organisation welcomes donations and makes the process quick and easy!
Giving platforms
Registering with an online giving platform can be a great way to make fundraising for your charity easy. JustGiving is an obvious example, but there are plenty of alternatives offering different benefits depending on your goals and budget.
This article by Charity Digital breaks down the pros and cons of some of the more prominent giving platforms (and introduces several lesser-known ones!), so could be a good starting point for organisations exploring their options.
Data capture and CRM systems
If we could recommend one investment to improve your digital fundraising performance, it would be a robust CRM system.
Effectively managing your network of supporters is crucial to your fundraising success. A good CRM system will bring all of your organisation’s relationships into one place, making it easier to approach them in a way that suits them. Additional benefits include donor segmentation for more targeted communication, better management of fundraising campaigns, and accurate reporting on the impact of your campaigns and activities.
With so many systems out there, it can be difficult to know where to start. This article by Expert Market looks at some of the best CRM systems for non-profits in 2022, providing a comparative breakdown of features and prices.
Marketing and communications
Raising the public profile of your charity or non-profit is obviously important to growing your pool of potential donors. Beyond that, it is crucial to gain an in-depth understanding of your supporters in order to develop meaningful, long-term relationships with them. Enter… marketing and communications!
Marketing data and donor-centric messaging
Much like any other business, market research for charities involves finding out as much as possible about your supporters and what it is that motivates them.
This could be something you bring in-house: by investing in a good CRM system and recruiting someone (or several people!) to specialise in your marketing. Alternatively, you can hire an external marketing agency to do this for you. Again, this decision is personal to you, and there are pros and cons of both approaches.
Once you’ve researched your potential supporters, you can use this data to develop a robust marketing strategy and donor-centric messages.
Digital marketing
As well as the impact that your donor journey can have on fundraising performance, it’s important to consider the content on your website and the story it tells. Emotion stimulates action, so a strong website is not only informative, but also stimulates an emotional response in its users. Investing in great content, be that blogs, case studies, stories, videos, etc. will help to build meaningful relationships with donors who care about your cause.
Social media is another important digital touchpoint. It’s a great way to keep your donors informed of the day-to-day activities of your charity and opens up exciting opportunities for viral campaigns. We’ve written a blog dedicated to using social media to boost fundraising performance, which analyses the benefits of different social platforms and provides tips on how charities can use them to reach their fundraising goals.
Traditional marketing
Don’t neglect the traditional approaches: after two years of disruption, in-person marketing and fundraising activities have made a strong come-back! Organising your own in-person event can be a lucrative investment, provided you have an engaged network of potential attendees and spread the word.
You could also consider becoming the charity partner of a corporate event – this allows you to gain the external exposure and fundraising revenue of a large event, without the same level of financial pressure!
Getting out there and speaking to people about your charity’s cause is still an effective and relatively inexpensive way to connect with potential donors. Personal interaction helps to build trust and generate support – even if you don’t get an immediate donation, you can share your charity’s story and put them in touch with your website.
Time
One final point! It’s important to understand the optimal mix of time management for your organisation when it comes to fundraising investment. For example, investing all your time into a major event only works if you have that engaged network of supporters who will come along and donate.
It’s back to that same old point, but truly understanding your charity’s resources, capabilities and capacity is key. Take those and look at them side by side with your fundraising goals, and you’ll see where you need to be investing time: it could be in networking with corporates, trusts and foundations, or building a seamless digital experience, or organising the gala of the year! Focussing on one or two areas is a better approach (and more realistic for most of us) than trying to nail everything at once.